There was a divide with New York Yankees fans earlier in the year when it was announced that stud hitting prospect Jesus Montero was being traded to the Mariners for Michael Pineda. While Pineda was 5th in the Rookie of the Year voting in 2011, his end of the season was less than stellar, while the call up of Montero went swimmingly well. He showed Yankee fans his quick bat speed and power and had them excited about what he could do over an entire season. But some fans were encouraged by the idea that the Yankees were getting themselves a big and tall righty that could really bring the the heat, and Montero wouldn’t have been anymore than a DH.
The concern has grown around Pineda all of Spring Training. His velocity, which often topped out at 97 MPH last season, has rarely seen 94. Yes, it may be early, and that is what Yankees fans were told about Phil Hughes last year, and Joba Chamberlain a couple years before that, when his overpowering fastball suddenly disappeared. Pineda hasn’t been terrible, but this isn’t what you trade your top prospect for. The Yanks kept Montero out of a lot of trades for dominating, front of the rotation pitchers before letting this trade happen. Pineda should be the solid #2 and now he might not even be on the Opening Day roster.
Yes, Pineda is likely to begin the year in the minors. Some will tell you that doesn’t mean it is time to panic, and they are right, but only because the Yankees have a ton of starting pitching to get the season started. But if one was to look at one spot on the Yankees roster and nitpick a glaring weakness, where would it be? Remember, this is an AL team. Which is why when people try to devalue Montero, it is silly. The DH matters in the AL, and his bat could have been a solid addition. He could hit righties and lefties, so there wouldn’t have been a need for a platoon at the DH position. Stick him in the meat of the Yanks order and you also provide him with protection. Or, he ends up protecting someone else. Instead, you have a pitching prospect that is heading back to the minors? That looks terrible.
Pineda showed up to camp about 20 lbs over what the Yankees expected. Right from the get-go, the kid put himself and his job on the line. He probably thought that he was the surefire #2 when the year began, but now he may need to get ready to ride the Greyhound to Scranton instead. It is hard to tell what that might do to the confidence of a guy that many believed was the next dominating power pitcher in the game. You also don’t trade one of, if not your best, prospect for a guy that you send back down to the minors.
The Yanks have tried to deflect the velocity issues by saying that he has more cut on this fastball and has developed a change-up, similar excuses they gave to Hughes a year ago. Pineda’s change-up isn’t going to make much of a difference if he isn’t throwing gas like he is supposed to.
Even if the Yankees keep Pineda in the rotation to being the year, the spotlight and pressure on him won’t stop. Remember, Montero was the piece that the Yankees continually refused to move, and Yankee fans have seen how easily he adapted to Major League pitching in his short stint last year. Pineda has to improve quickly, or the fans and the media are going to eat him alive in the Bronx.
This may even drive Frank Costanza even more crazy than the Jay Buhner for Ken Phelps trade.
Update: Pineda to undergo an MRI